Studying teachers’ knowledge management is also an entry point to studying knowledge management in the field of education. To guarantee the healthy and continuous development of teachers’ knowledge management ability, it is crucial to evaluate their management level in a scientific, objective and comprehensive way. Using the expert consultation and analytic hierarchy process (AHP), we put forward and set up an evaluation index system for college teachers’ knowledge management, we evaluated the knowledge management levels of college teachers. The results showed that rankings of knowledge management levels of college teachers were knowledge acquisition, knowledge organization, knowledge development and knowledge innovation from high to low. Their knowledge management was above the average as a whole. From all levels, the scores of knowledge acquisition and knowledge organization were relatively high.